data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d087d/d087d6522028922558885c6d9add4492b016441d" alt="Let's be honest... the tentacles between the eyes is basically an elephant trunk."
The benevolent octopus of capitalism reaches out to comfort all.
Poverty is the default state. It requires no explanation for its origin.
Prosperity comes from improvements to the means of production. Those improvements require capital, which accumulates through savings. Savings are the result of under-consumption. To put it another way, if nobody saves, there is nothing to borrow or spend on improvements.
When people are able to save, produce, and trade freely, prosperity tends to come automatically. Unfortunately, the free market has many opponents. There are two main groups. One is groups seeking to stifle competition, such as established businesses, cartels, and labor unions. The other is control freaks upset that people are buying what they want instead of what the control freaks want. The amount of power these groups have set the limit on how prosperous a community can be.
Instead of letting the market create prosperity automatically, these groups stall the process with absurd, self-serving rules and then demand that the government step in to stimulate the economy when stagnation results. A good example of one such rule was a former law which outlawed the sale of margarine colored to look like butter. Dairy farmers complained this was “unfair” competition, and so demanded a law to stifle their competitors. Some states even passed requiring margarine to be dyed pink to make it less appealing. A margarine dye law stayed on the books in Quebec until 2008. Margarine was invented in 1871.
The stagnation that results from the accumulation of stupid laws creates pressure for a central bank and periodic attempts to “jump-start” the economy, usually by expanding credit artificially and/or increasing government spending. These credit expansions create a temporary boom followed by an inevitable bust.
The best way to understand this is to imagine a restaurant owner in a small town. One week, the circus comes and he has many new customers. For some reason, he doesn’t notice they are all clowns and lion tamers. He decides to open another restaurant to handle all the new business. But soon the circus leaves town, and he is forced close the second restaurant. In this example, it is all the fault of the restaurant owner’s poor judgment.
In another case, bad weather can cause farmers to lose money. But if every farmer in a country has a bad harvest for years on end, it is unlikely that the weather is the culprit. The farms of the USSR had been some of the world’s most productive for centuries. Yet as soon as the communists took over they proceeded to have 70 years of bad harvests, which the communists blamed on the weather. A common joke in the USSR was that if communists took over the Sahara, in a year, there would be a shortage of sand.
It is the same in a recession when thousands of businesses of all kinds lose money at the same time. The question becomes: why did all these different businesses make the same mistake at the same time? Why did so many people choose to start or expand businesses doomed to fail? The answer is that credit was expanded artificially by a central bank.
Poverty and economic crises are man-made. When the Roman emperors wanted more money without raising taxes or cutting spending, they issued coins with less silver. But since the new coins were worth less, prices rose. The Emperor Diocletian tried to stop inflation by fixing prices. A Roman historian at the time observed he might as well have commanded the wind not to blow.
Just as inflation has been blamed on everything except an increase in the amount of money, economic crises have blamed on everything except credit expansions by central banks. The worst economic crisis in history happened a mere 13 years after the creation of the Federal Reserve, America’s central bank.
The idea that printing money, expanding credit by fiat, or increasing government spending will somehow magically lead to prosperity is no different than trying to drink yourself sober or put out a fire with gasoline.
It is high time for the proponents of flat earth economics to relent and repent.
Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded — here and there, now and then — are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty.
This is known as “bad luck.”
― Robert A. Heinlein
Do you think that the problem with communism is that they have not yet had the right people in charge?
The people weren’t good enough, they needed a New Soviet Man.
Obama approves.
Also that they haven’t been in charge of the right people. Too many wreckers and kulaks. I’m just sure that if we drop Bernie Sanders and all of his supporters (and none of his detractors) in a country like Venezuela they’d have a socialist utopia up and running in no time. Yup yup.
Obama identified them as clingers, or something like that.
That + kulaks, hoarders, and wreckers.
Absolutely. Once they get the right recipe in place…WATCH OUT!
Nice to see this as a non comment.
If I understand correctly God made poverty – it was after all in the begining- and enlightened progressives are trying to end it but are obstructed by the ignorant religious and selfish libertarians. Is that it?
We are the 1-4.9%
Secretly controlling everything.
We are The Gliberati.
Ooh new logo ideas. Gliberati eyes and weird mason shit.
Weird mason shit Like This
Better Mason Symbolism
Oh, CORN in a jar. Whew.
Pyramid design with tophat and monocle, being held aloft by orphans?
something like that.
Gliberati confirmed.
Ot, whats with the hate for pineapple pizza I’m seeing on the internet? It’s not like i put it in a casserole.
Pizza with bacon and pineapple is delicious. Anyone who says otherwise has stinky egg breath.
There’s a place nearby that has a delicious pizza with some canadian bacon, bacon, pineapple, and jalapenos.
Pineapple is disgusting in any shape or form, to use it to ruin sonething decent is even worse
Would you like a tic-tac?
ouch, PITS.
Mix it with Pernod to appreciate the pineapple.
Because it’s a stupid fucking idea which only a drooling moron or a Canadian could tolerate.
*wipes chin*
huh?
Here’s the extent of stuff that is not meat which is allowed on a pizza:
tomatoes (as in sauce)
cheese
mushrooms
peppers
olives
Anything else, it’s no longer pizza, it’s… it’s.. it’s a fucking abomination!
I might allow onions.
I don’t put onions on pizza, but yeah, that sounds allowable.
So many Pizza Nazis.
I’ll have the 16″ Abomination with extra pineapple, and a coke, please.
That sounds way dirtier than I meant it to.
I presume you mean 16″ thick.
That’s some thicc pizza.
Banana curry pizza with pineapple or GTFO of Sweden.
Quattro stagione has artichokes mofo. Pistols at dawn.
Fuck Olives.
I would rather eat pizza with dried minnows on it.
New name for anchovies?
I was really coming to like you, Doom. Why, oh why, did you have to fuck that up?
*grins sheepishly*
To keep it on topic, I guess there is no end of market silliness. If someone is so misguided as to buy a flat, disc-shaped food item with pineapple on it, that is mistakenly called “pizza,” someone will be enough of a greedy capitalist to produce it.
A huzzah for capitalism!
I will work my way back into your heart, SP.
And I’ll buy you a pineapple bacon pizza.
Be strong!
Not the Kochtopus! Nooooo!
It’s funny how much “progressives” hate Koch Industries – mainly for their political activities – when they are outspent by a large margin by the AFSCME, SEIU, American Federation of Teachers, and many other leftist organizations.
In fact, this gives me an idea for an article to submit here: “Big Money on the Left”. Most people think that “big money” is a right-wing thing, but there are tons of counterexamples. If I can stop drinking so much and taking so many naps, I might write it.
When I finished reading this part of the sentence: “Some states even passed requiring margarine to be dyed pink”, I was thinking “that’s fucking absurd…”
Then I read this part: “A margarine dye law stayed on the books in Quebec until 2008″, I thought “oh, ok, we’re talking about Canada.”
Hey now, we’re talking about Quebec, thank you very much.
/English Canada
Well answer me that one, smart guy : How can you tell the difference between margarine and butter if both of them can be yellowish?
Impossible you say! You’re right! Now who will protect our milk cartels from those evil margarine vulture capitalists?
It’s complete anarchy over here now I tell you! I’m surprised we still have roads.
I believe that margarine in its “pure” form is white. I have heard of old laws that prevented it from being dyed yellow, and that as a result some was sold with separate packets of yellow dye for consumers to mix in after purchase.
Irony: margarine is actually terrible for you, and government attempts to suppress it probably had health benefits.
Lest we forget that the FDA proscription on animal fats drove the trans fats of margarine to higher consumption…
Yup.
That is absurd; There is no possible way to make margarine less appealing than it already is.
Which reminds me: someone on the Old Site recommended Kerrygold Irish butter, which I tried and OMG it’s wonderful. Like butter x2. Highly recommended.
That may have been me. I love that stuff.
“But… we’re killing the planet and clean energy is the only solution,” DiCaprio said.
“Wait, I won’t be able to afford my rent if I have to pay for your clean energy policies!” said the unenlightened prole.
“We all have to make sacrifices, ” said DiCapcrio as he rushed off to his plane to speak at a climate conference halfway across the world.
While his eyebrow stylist gets there on a different plane
Eyebrow stylists cannot be done without. That sacrifice is a bridge too far. And besides, he already made one sacrifice. He usually employs two eyebrow stylists, one for each eyebrow, who happen to live equally far in opposite directions. Hasn’t he given up enough for you?
Not just climate conferences, there was some soccer match he had to fly to on a intercontinental private jet after making similar Gaian genuflections a while back. L. Ron Hubbard knew what he was doing with his program to recruit Hollywood celebrities, that’s for sure. Lots of money, little reflection.
I thought poverty was caused by rich people not paying their fair share. /s
It is, now days. And the proof is that America’s 400 lb poor folks would weigh 600 lbs if the rich just start paying their fair share.
As a note using a line lie “letting the market create prosperity automatically,”with non-libertarians can be counterproductive as they will accuse you of believing in a magical market that makes things. It is better imo to be clear that the market is a metaphor for people acting, and as such people create the wealth. The market, not unlike Soylent Green, is just people
Also lefties will be inclined to randomly scream market failure. Libertarians should point out that free market is simply a broad term that describes the sum of all human action on earth. It is not an entity, it does not have plans and hopes and dreams. The outcomes of the market may not be what some people think the outcomes should be, but this is not a failure, just like a plane crash is not a failure of gravity.
“The free market is not a creed or an ideology that political conservatives, libertarians, and Ayn Rand acolytes want Americans to take on faith. The free market is simply a measurement. The free market tells us what people are willing to pay for a given thing at a given moment. That’s all the free market does. The free market is a bathroom scale. We may not like what we see when we step on the bathroom scale, but we can’t pass a law making ourselves weigh 165. Liberals and leftists think we can.” —P.J. O’Rourke
P.J. is a national treasure.
How can anyone say this, then vote for Hillary. At least stay home. You don’t have to vote like in the fascist lands of Australia.
I voted for Darrell Castle, of the Constitution Party.
Which, I’ve been told is the same as voting for Hillary.
I meant PJ voting for Hillary. Sorry for the in-clarity with my use of the word “you”
When I lived in Tupelo, MS, I strongly recommended Eat the Rich by O’Rourke to an African-American young man. Afterwards, I remembered that he uses the “N” word in the book.
Niggardly?
“Nectarine”. He put it on his pizza.
Ok. You can try this with the left. But first of all, you go in knowing they do not deal with logic and cold hard facts. They deal with ‘feelz’.
And this is where the trouble begins. People are corruptible, and so some people will wind up with all the goodies and then will become robber barons and exploit the rest of the people. So the only solution then is government, which is NOT people, and therefore not corruptible.
It’s not paranoia if the market really is out to get you.
Fuck!
Fuckfuckfuckfuckfuckfuckfuckfuck!
I looked in my closet and I think the free market might be hiding in there, ready to pounce. Oh, government, please save me from the inevitable market failure it’s got plotted to make a pauper of me! I throw myself at your beneficent mercy and ask you to violence that market so that it may never harm me again.
I say the same prayer nightly before bed.
The market is always out to get us, as in ‘get some of our limited supply of money’.
The distinction to be made is that it’s BAD when private entities try to sell you things and you buy them because you want to. It’s GOOD when government forces you to buy stuff that you don’t even want. See how this works?
So you are saying Samsung stole my money when I bought that TV. God damn I’ve been robbed, this is what the market does to people
Don’t worry, when the progs win and usher in the great utopia, only government will make TVs and everyone will have the same black and white 19″ model with the rabbit ears antenna and no remote. Remotes contribute to obesity.
But you will be able to watch up to 8 hours of official party speeches a day on the only channel, so it will be worth it.
The Trabant was such a fantastic vehicle that you had to be put on a waiting list to get one, like at a fancy club. Sure it ate oil and didn’t like to start in the winter, but those are a small price to pay for the equality of practically everyone not having one. It was OK that good party members got to cut the queue. Some people are just more equal than others.
No one needs 3 TV channels.
That thing looks like something only a Eurotard could feel smug about driving.
Oh the trabant was a fantastic piece of machinery. It could go a the way to 55 mph downhill with the wind at your back, it rattled and made a horrible noise, and if you drove it for a couple of hundred kilometers you would get a horrible headache. But it was practically made of cardboard so it was cheap to fix. And, believe it or not, it was better than nothing.
It did start in the winter with a little work. That is if you cued overnight for gas.
It sounds like the K Car that my mum had, which I had the misfortune of having to borrow once when my car was in the shop. I drove it about 12 miles and I almost got up to 50 with the peddle mashed to the floor after 11 miles. If not for that damn tractor that pulled out on the road.
Americans shall never know the pleasure of driving a trabant in winter to your unheated apartment in an god awful concrete brutality communist apartment bloc. Or I dunno give it 20 years …
It’s a good thing that trying to acquire anything other than a Trabant would earn you a visit from the Stasi, unless you were very high up in the party, of course.
Here’s a Wikipedia page with several good jokes about the Trabant.
Sadly I can’t seem to comment on the Trabant threads.
Anyway, some are still for sale in my neighborhood though I think most have had a VW engine dropped in and are kept alive for ironic nostalgia.
No. Samsung isnt stealing from you when you buy toys. Drug companies are stealing from you when you guy drugs (non-narcotics) and grocery stores when you buy food. Shiny, fun toys are a different matter altogether.
It’s almost like you don’t think the economy is a zero sum game. *bites nails*
free market is simply a broad term that describes the sum of all voluntary, economic human action on earth.
The market, praise be its name, is not the entire human universe.
Eh in the end a lot of things are economic activity. I can think of few activities that do not imply some …
a lot of =/= everything
I do a lot of things for non-economic reasons, and I bet you do, too.
These euphemisms.
I was thinking “Commenting at the Glib”, but yeah, that works, too.
But if you wind up accidentally educating someone about economics, they might start behaving differently and affect the market. It might be your dastardly plan for commenting on the topic!
Great article Derp. keeps it simple for idiots like myself who still have a lot to learn. Very Stossel-like. Thanks man.
Some states even passed requiring margarine to be dyed pink to make it less appealing. A margarine dye law stayed on the books in Quebec until 2008. Margarine was invented in 1871.
Ah yes, the Margarine Wars, a particularly stupid period of Canadian history. I actually had an entire three hour class on it in university.
Outlawed in Wisconsin too — people had to drive to Iowa to get it. Then it turned out it kills you, so I guess the cheeseheads got the last laugh.
I recall that in New York State,
some time in the Fifties, margarine
was white, but was packaged with a
small red pill that could be kneaded
into the margarine till it looked
somewhat like yellow butter.
I picked up my first Heinlein book after reading that quote. He reached Twain or Mencken level with that one. Wouldn’t necessarily say that about his books.
OT: Wicked Game (Gemma Hayes Remix)
But why?
Because.
Also we must remember that wealth and capital are the same thing as nominal fiat money, so printing money obviously increases capital, which would be insufficient otherwise, so this is why central banks are needed. Further more it would be stupid to let human preference set the interest rates, everyone knows the central bank can set them juuust right.
It’s worked perfectly so far!
I’ll see if I can get Alex over here to explain fractional reserve banking and lizard moon beams to us.
mister jones himself?!
Yeah, but I had to rethink that, I don’t want the catass avatar.
I think SP may catass me for my transgressions of the day.
Is the correct term “catass” or “catbutt”?
Catass has the better ring to it.
It’s worked perfectly so far!
Like jumping off a building…
“So far, so good!”
Throughout history, poverty is the normal condition of man. Advances which permit this norm to be exceeded — here and there, now and then — are the work of an extremely small minority, frequently despised, often condemned, and almost always opposed by all right-thinking people. Whenever this tiny minority is kept from creating, or (as sometimes happens) is driven out of a society, the people then slip back into abject poverty.
This is known as ̶ ̶”̶b̶a̶d̶ ̶l̶u̶c̶k̶.̶”̶ Venezuela.
No, Trump caused Venezuela. Retroactively somehow.
Great article, Derpy. Moar pleez.
Great article. I think it benefited well from the polish you added to it from the version you posted in the comments. Keep up the good work!
Everyone look at Derp. See Derp? Take a bow Derp.
This is how you write an article. Simple, articulate and straight to the heart of the issue.
In all seriousness it would be great if we had more articles that covered the basics like this. Sooner or later this site is going to get a lot of hits from non-libertarian minded people who have been told that we all have fangs and eat babies, that we are jackbooted exploiters. More basic stuff so that people can be exposed to the real thing in our own words would be great. I cant think of any other site (wink wink) that does a good job of that. So far this site is off to a pretty good start and I cant overstate what a good job the site’s founders are doing.
Question, the article says “Poverty is the default state…” then later says “Poverty and economic crises are man made…”. How can it be both?